Wednesday, Oct 07 , 2015 ( Thul-Hijjah, 1436)

Updated:10:00 PM GMT

Islam-Evolution Debate Raises UK Uproar

OnIslam & Newspapers

Evolution Stirs UK Muslim Debates
The Deen Institute has canceled its plans to hold a conference entitled “Have Muslims misunderstood evolution?”
Islam, evolution, controversy

CAIRO – Plans by a Muslim forum to hold a debate on Islam and evolution at one of Britain's top scientific universities have been shelved over opposition from Muslim students.

"It’s symptomatic of a bigger problem in the Muslim world where people representing practical Muslims have to be seen to be more literalist,” Adam Deen, co-founder of the Deen Institute, told The Independent on Saturday, December 15.

"It’s almost like there’s an intellectual mafia movement who won’t allow any freedom of thought."

Creation or Evolution?

Evolution in the Light of Islam

Rethinking Darwin

Bridging the Gap Between Evolution and Faith

Darwinism from an Islamic Perspective

The Deen Institute, a Muslim debating forum which promotes critical thinking, has planned to hold a conference entitled “Have Muslims misunderstood evolution?” early next year.

Speakers invited at the event included Muslim scientists, imams who have promoted the compatibility of Islam and evolution as well as those who preach a form of Islamic creationism.

Deen, who describes himself as a “conservative Muslim” who encourages critical thinking, said he was surprised to face such opposition at a place of scientific study.

"As soon as it went live I was inundated with complaints,” one source involved with preparations said.

“It’s sad because student societies should be desperate to host this kind of debate.”

Facing opposition from Muslim students, the Institute said it was forced to pull out when it became clear that opposition to the event from supporters of creationism began mounting.

It is now being held without input from any Muslim student society at Logan Hall, a conference center owned by the University of London.

“We eventually had to give up of getting any support from student societies because it was seen as simply too controversial,” Deen said.

Dr Oktar Babuna, a representative from the prominent Turkish theologian Harun Yahya movement, is scheduled to speak at the conference alongside Sheikh Yasir Qadhi, an influential imam who accepts evolution at a micro level but refuses the idea that man evolved from anything other than Adam himself.

Two Muslim scientists; American biologists Ehab Abouheif and Fatimah Jackson, will also speak alongside Usama Hasan, a British imam who preaches the commonly held scientific view that man is descended from ape-like forebears.


The divisions was also evident on a Facebook launched by the co-founder of the Deen Institute.

"If our faith is strong we can only gain from looking at, hearing and understanding difference,” wrote Amina Crashaw who criticized their colleagues for shunning scientific research.

"If this were not truth I would not be Muslim. Understanding difference include being open to finding something new to learn from the Qur’an. Not new facts but new depth."

Others were upset with the idea of bringing the issue of Darwinism into debate.

“This debate is a big mistake,” wrote Mohammad Ali Harrath, the founder of the highly influential Islam Channel.

"It is shifting debate to make it a Muslim issue rather than an issue between atheists and creationists.”

Another commenter, Zeshan Sasjid, shares a similar view.

"Evolution is not Islamic,” he said.

“Prophet Adam did not have parents. A Muslim can’t believe that.”

Darwin's On The Origin of Species — published in 1859 and translated in full into Arabic in the mid-1870s — has been at the center of a long-running debate, albeit one with varying intensity.

A hundred and fifty years later, Darwin remains a source of troubles in the Arab and Muslim worlds.

Many Muslim scientists today accept Darwin's theory, often within the understanding that the evolutionary process was preceded by a moment of creation that the divine God had willed and carried out.

Harun Yahya (pen-name of author Adnan Oktar) has published several glossy tomes aimed at discrediting evolution as an unsupportable theory and portraying Darwin as an atheist whose ideas (allied with Communism) were part of a larger project to undermine all religions.
Related Links:
Creationism Attack Under UK Muslim Fire
UK School Teaches Faiths Respect
Preserve Faith Schools: Religious Leaders

Add comment

Security code